blog.bitmain.com

Cryptocurrency, Bitcoin, Bitmain and more...

Regarding Recent Allegations and Smear Campaigns

 

When the concept of Bitcoin was first introduced on a cryptography mailing list by Satoshi Nakamoto, certain developers purported to have already “proven that decentralized consensus was impossible”. Today, the same developers offer a similarly specious “proof” that the implementation of long-published ASIC optimizations is some kind of “attack” on the Bitcoin network.

We’d like to clear the air.

Bitmain has tested ASICBOOST on the Testnet but has never used ASICBOOST on the mainnet as implied in Gregory Maxwell’s proposal. We ask conclusive proof from whoever claims this to be false because such baseless claims are toxic for the Bitcoin space. We also believe the math used by Gregory Maxwell is incorrect and that the method is not practical in a production environment.

Our ASIC chips, like those of some other manufacturers, have a circuit design that supports ASICBOOST. However, the ASICBOOST method has not been used by us on the mainnet. We have not seen any evidence yet on the main net that anyone has used it in the patented way.

Bitmain holds the ASICBOOST patent in China. We can legally use it in our own mining farms in China to profit from it and sell the cloud mining contracts to the public. This, however profitable, is not something we would do for the greater good of Bitcoin.

The mining equipment produced by Bitmain for its own use is in no way intended to be technically superior or more power-efficient than the equipment it sells to the public. The ASICBOOST method has not been employed by Bitmain to increase the power-efficiency of the miners in its own mining farms.

Bitcoin mining equipment depreciates rapidly. Bitmain has constantly been introducing newer more efficient miner models for all. As such the statement that the deployment of ASICBOOST, which can lead to a 20% difference in power efficiency, is some kind of negative development for Bitmain’s business model is false. Bitmain has shown the ability to adapt and thrive in the constantly changing and extremely challenging Bitcoin mining environment. Whether ASICBOOST is used or not, Bitmain will continue to produce more efficient miners.

Bitmain had always supported the Hong Kong Agreement, which means Segwit plus a hard fork to 2MB block size, until we no longer felt that it was going to happen in the foreseeable future. In fact, Bitmain is publicly on record as historically supporting SegWit and Lightning Network in the context of the Hong Kong agreement, and any accusations to the contrary are completely false and specious.

Miners love multi-layer solutions like Lightning Network. To support these off-chain solutions, Bitmain is very supportive of fixing malleability issues. At the same time, we also believe the first layer, which has been well-tested by time, is very important and should not be crippled. We are worried about the policy and precedence set by Bitcoin Core in this regard.

Tothemoon”, an extension blocks plan proposed recently by Purse.io using a new Bitcon protocol implementation called Bcoin, could be designed to be incompatible with ASICBOOST much like Segwit is. ASICBOOST is not a deterrent to Bitmain’s support of SegWit or Tothemoon. SegWit is not running in production because the conditions made clear in the Hong Kong agreement have not been met, in which we foresee a non-witness block size increase coming together with SegWit. Bitmain’s co-CEO Jihan Wu has clearly expressed support for Tothemoon recently. Tothemoon is a real and standard block size increase, but not through an arbitrary witness discount policy.

Gregory Maxwell’s recent proposal suggests changing 2^32 collision to 2^64 collision to make ASICBOOST more difficult. The result of this would be a loss for the patent owners and the Bitcoin protocol. The patent owners will get nothing and Bitcoin protocol will become more complicated. The only beneficiary will be the technical bureaucrats who are engineering it. The more complicated the protocol is, the higher the cost and barrier to have multiple implementations become. We confirm that we support multiple implementations because they will bring more innovation and better security to the network, while threatening the monopolistic position of certain developers.

Bitmain has continuously been advocating for increasing the Bitcoin block size. Increasing the block size will make the collisions even more difficult, damaging the potential benefits of Bitmain’s gain from the private ASICBOOST assumed by Maxwell’s proposal. The conspiracy theories do not add up here.

There are better ways to resolve the issues that Gregory Maxwell’s proposal seeks to address. Adversarial thinking is not the only way. We suggest working with the patent owners so that the patent could be used by the public. If all mining equipment could use ASICBOOST, it will lower the J/GH cost and the total network hash rate will increase, making the Bitcoin network even stronger. So, the ASICBOOST method is not a “covert attack” on the Bitcoin PoW function. It is an engineering optimization.

The best method to leverage ASICBOOST is by using the Bitcoin block header’s version bits. Patent owner Timo has mentioned it in the patent. Gregory Maxwell’s proposal seems to be missing this point. Usage of these bits was proposed by Timo Hanke through Bitcoin Core’s BIP process but it was declined by Gregory Maxwell and Core developers.

Bitcoin Core is now almost controlled by a small secretive committee. Anyone with a basic sense about human history can tell that this is the starting of a dictatorship. Calling out an optimization an “attack” is playing a political trick to grab power.

The proposal mentions “reverse engineering of a particular mining chip demonstrated conclusively that ASICBOOST has been implemented”. This statement seems directed towards Bitmain. We believe the Bitcoin community needs more constructive contributors than it needs such policing.

The proposal does not mention Bitmain, however, an orchestrated troll army within the community was effectively able to spread rumors around Bitmain. Most Bitcoin companies currently have a strong fear of such notorious assets working for certain people. Bitcoin’s value of liberty is in danger.

The Bitcoin community suffered a grave misfortune when Maxwell lead the coup against Gavin Andresen and removed his Github commit access. It is now incumbent upon us as a community to figure out how to find a new core developer group that does not busy itself with attacking one of Bitcoin’s largest investors (Ver), one of its largest exchanges (Coinbase), and its largest mining equipment provider (Bitmain).

There is a history of character assassinations against those who have spoken against SegWit or Core’s roadmap. Gregory Maxwell’s latest round of attempts follow his previous patterns. Maxwell has previously attacked one of most important Bitcoin maintainers Gavin Andresen, one of the earliest public Bitcoin advocates and investors Roger Ver, founder and CEO of one of the largest Bitcoin exchanges Brian Armstrong, the first author of Lightning Network Joseph Poon, and now Bitmain’s co-CEO Jihan Wu. He has even called his fellow Core contributors who signed the Hong Kong agreement “dipshits”. Such hostility is destructive for Bitcoin.

We have very firm belief that the block size of Bitcoin will be increased. It is the Bitcoin that our co-founders signed up for, it is the roadmap designed by Satoshi and it is the destiny of Bitcoin. We will protect it at any cost.

---------------------
Liked this article? Share it with others:

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedin
Follow Us for Latest News & Articles:

Facebooktwittergoogle_pluslinkedin

73 Comments

  1. SegWit is a block size limit increase.

  2. wow, talk about a smackdown. of Gregory Maxwell.

    and well deserved. thank you.

  3. Bitch, please. You’re busted.

  4. Bullshit.

  5. Does Bitmain then support BU?

  6. “We have very firm belief that the block size of Bitcoin will be increased. It is the Bitcoin that our co-founders signed up for, it is the roadmap designed by Satoshi and it is the destiny of Bitcoin. We will protect it at any cost.”

    I <3 this.

  7. I think the statement here is a bit suspicious. There is denial that Bitmain uses ASICBOOST on the mainnet, however ASICBOOST is also defended, as an optimization, at the same time.

    > Bitmain holds the ASICBOOST patent in China. We can legally use it in our own mining farms in China to profit from it and sell the cloud mining contracts to the public. This, however profitable, is not something we would do for the greater good of Bitcoin.

    > Gregory Maxwell’s recent proposal suggests changing 2^32 collision to 2^64 collision to make ASICBOOST more difficult. The result of this would be a loss for the patent owners and the Bitcoin protocol.

    Are these statements not contradictions? If one should not use ASICBOOST for the greater good of Bitcoin, then why shouldn’t covert ASICBOOST be stopped?

    > If all mining equipment could use ASICBOOST, it will lower the J/GH cost and the total network hash rate will increase, making the Bitcoin network even stronger.

    I am not sure this makes Bitcoin stronger. ASICBOOST enables the miners to find a valid hash using less work. If all miners did this, that would not make Bitcoin stronger. This seems to be a fundamental misunderstanding of the security model.

    Proof of Work is about proving work has been done, doing less work does not increase the proof of work. Covertly hiding that less work has been done, definitely does not make Bitcoin stronger.

  8. LiberateBitcoin

    April 7, 2017 at 11:01 pm

    This is the most important part regarding to the scaling war:

    “At the same time, we also believe the first layer, which has been well-tested by time, is very important and should not be crippled”

    BlockstreamCore proved on a thousand occasions that they want to keep Bitcoin crippled. One can only guess if it’s because they want to push users offchain, or just to damage Bitcoin.

    As for the latest attack on Bitmain. Not surprising considering what happened in the past 2 years.

    Blockstream attacks everyone who goes against their agenda and they utilize an organized troll army and the censored pro-blockstream forums.

    The only way to liberate Bitcoin is to reject Core and switch to bcoin/classic/BU.

  9. Nunya Bidness

    April 8, 2017 at 3:06 am

    Full of shit.

  10. I wonder what makes the ASICBoost illegitmate, while the move to GPU and ASIC Ming was legitimate..
    And ain’t it advantageous to bitcoin network to encourage such innovation, which will improve the efficiency of mining and consequently reducing mining cost per bitcoin, and also reducing the cost of transaction confirmation.

    • Yes M Elzubier, it is advantageous to the Bitcoin network and we hope the patent could be free to use by the public. That is why we already made our Bitcoin miners future-ready so everyone can take advantage of the patent when it becomes available for public use. We are trying our best to make that happen.

  11. Awaiting moderation

    Regards, A lot of stuff.

    viagra falls play viagra message boards
    viagra for sale uk
    levitra vs viagra vs cialis – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  12. Awaiting moderation

    Thanks a lot! I like it.

    viagra colitis cheap viagra profisional line only uk
    viagra for sale uk
    overnight delivery viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  13. Awaiting moderation

    Wonderful content, Thank you.

    phentermine and viagra viagra replacements
    generic viagra
    herb works as well as viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  14. Awaiting moderation

    Nicely put. Many thanks!

    viagra commercials tv commercials citrate generic name sildenafil viagra
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    viagra generic comments – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  15. Awaiting moderation

    Kudos! I appreciate it.

    2 50 mg viagra viagra kamagra vs
    viagra for sale uk
    time to take effect viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  16. Awaiting moderation

    Really a good deal of superb tips.

    shelf life viagra generic comparison viagra regalis levitra
    viagra without a doctors prescription
    viagra viagra a a target blank – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  17. Awaiting moderation

    Nicely put. Thanks a lot!

    viagra online order subaction showcomments viagra thanks watch
    viagra online
    canada viagra cheap – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  18. Awaiting moderation

    Amazing quite a lot of awesome advice!

    viagra dallas no prescription online viagra and nitrites
    viagra pills
    viagra inventors men of kent – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  19. Awaiting moderation

    Nicely put, Thanks a lot.

    real viagra overnight generic viagra soft 100
    buy viagra online
    viagra oral jelly – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  20. Awaiting moderation

    Thank you, I value this.

    viagra home office photo valium viagra interaction
    viagra 100mg
    viagra photos – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  21. Awaiting moderation

    You actually mentioned this exceptionally well!

    viagra dangerous for young people viagra uden recept
    cheap viagra
    buy chinese herbal viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  22. Awaiting moderation

    You expressed that superbly.

    viagra med uk cant get hardon with viagra
    buy viagra online
    viagra caffeine – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  23. Awaiting moderation

    Nicely put. Appreciate it!

    cardiac bypass surgery and viagra viagra in the waters kareoke
    viagra without a doctors prescription
    best place to get viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  24. Awaiting moderation

    You said it very well..

    generic viagra on sale taking viagra and cialis together
    buy generic viagra
    viva viagra elvis – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  25. Awaiting moderation

    Seriously many of amazing data.

    purple viagra noni slogans for viagra joke
    buy generic viagra
    female enhancement liquid version viagra niagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  26. Awaiting moderation

    Wonderful content. Thanks a lot!

    stop viagra flushing find viagra free sites search computer
    buy viagra online
    cheap generic viagra no prescription – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  27. Awaiting moderation

    Whoa plenty of fantastic material!

    find search viagra free computer edinburgh viagra covered by kaiser insurance
    viagra for sale uk
    viagra for diabetes – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  28. Awaiting moderation

    Good postings. Kudos.

    viagra versus lavitra cialis compare levitra viagra
    buy generic viagra
    why you shouldn’t take viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  29. Awaiting moderation

    Thank you. I like it!

    discount viagra tm dr oz viagra
    viagra pills
    viagra hearing problems – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  30. Awaiting moderation

    You explained it effectively!

    viagra by post will viagra keep erection after climax
    generic viagra online
    about buy viagra online links – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  31. Awaiting moderation

    Great write ups. Kudos.

    time of day to take viagra viagra alternative ne
    buy viagra online
    viagra online overnight delivery – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  32. Awaiting moderation

    Thanks a lot! Quite a lot of material.

    viagra half price pharmacy viagra sale uk
    buy viagra
    pages edinburgh search viagra free – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  33. Awaiting moderation

    Whoa lots of great info.

    viagra lisinopril interaction how much arginine is in viagra
    viagra without a doctors prescription
    viagra super active in australia – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  34. Awaiting moderation

    You said it adequately!

    viagra patent up herbal viagra uk
    viagra generic
    viagra and bodybuilding – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  35. Awaiting moderation

    You suggested it superbly.

    lady viagra side effects viagra in bulgaria
    buy viagra online
    jack nicholson quote viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  36. Awaiting moderation

    Reliable write ups. Thanks a lot!

    viagra will what viagra galloway
    generic viagra 100mg
    kaboom answer to viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  37. Awaiting moderation

    Factor nicely applied!!

    how long odes viagra last theodore schenk counterfit viagra
    viagra online
    what does viagra cost at walgreens – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  38. Awaiting moderation

    Many thanks. Awesome stuff.

    moo moo edinburgh viagra tid cfm photos of viagra users
    viagra for women
    natural herbs that act like viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  39. Awaiting moderation

    Thank you. A good amount of stuff!

    order viagra online a href iframe helping viagra work
    viagra online
    male enhancment viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  40. Awaiting moderation

    Nicely put, Thank you!

    discount viagra and ciallis viagra uk site
    generic viagra 100mg
    next day delivery generic viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  41. Awaiting moderation

    Great content, With thanks!

    test done on viagra viagra testosterone mail order
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    women talk about viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  42. Awaiting moderation

    Superb information. Thanks.

    edinburgh viagra find sites posted u s viagra by mail
    viagra pills
    taking viagra and using tens – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  43. Awaiting moderation

    Thanks a lot, Quite a lot of info!

    how do i purchase viagra more sperm on viagra
    buy viagra
    online cheap viagra buy – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  44. Awaiting moderation

    You explained it fantastically.

    side effect viagra multiple erections viagra
    viagra pills
    viagra experiences – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  45. Awaiting moderation

    Tips very well considered!.

    how to buy viagra in budapest viagra samples free generic
    buy viagra online
    stories of viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  46. Awaiting moderation

    Excellent posts. Regards.

    snoring and viagra get viagra drug online
    buy generic viagra
    viagra ginko – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  47. Awaiting moderation

    Very good facts. Thanks a lot!

    discount viagra online do i need presciption for viagra
    cheap viagra
    government viagra tests results – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  48. Awaiting moderation

    Kudos, Numerous information!

    bid 2836 viagra criteria for nhs viagra prescription
    buy generic viagra
    jokes viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  49. Awaiting moderation

    Thanks! A lot of stuff!

    viagra lowest price generic purchase viagra uk
    buy generic viagra
    best generic viagra site – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  50. Awaiting moderation

    Beneficial write ups. Thanks a lot.

    viagra rebate free sample viagra
    generic viagra online
    canadian pharmacy viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  51. Awaiting moderation

    You reported that terrifically.

    viagra s fre viagra
    generic viagra online
    viagra hyper – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  52. Awaiting moderation

    You suggested it very well!

    viagra vending laws generic cialis free viagra
    buy viagra online
    clininc viagra prescriptions charlotte nc – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  53. Awaiting moderation

    Wonderful tips. Cheers.

    isosorb viagra interactions viagra windsor
    viagra for sale uk
    viagra sildenafil cialis tadalafil dosage use – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  54. Awaiting moderation

    Nicely put, Appreciate it!

    enhancing the viagra review viagra generic mastercard precription
    viagra 100mg
    seinfeld and viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  55. Awaiting moderation

    You actually stated that terrifically.

    viagra testimony purchase viagra soft tabs
    viagra generic
    viagra and cialis together – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  56. Awaiting moderation

    Thanks a lot. Numerous posts.

    viagra interaction with muscle relaxant search viagra viagra find edinburgh free
    generic viagra 100mg
    when does viagra go off patent – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  57. Awaiting moderation

    Great advice. Kudos!

    practical benefits of viagra viagra massage
    buy viagra
    viagras by vbulletin – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  58. Awaiting moderation

    With thanks. Ample postings.

    cheap viagra kamagra getting rid of viagra emails
    buy viagra
    viagra for recreational use – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  59. Awaiting moderation

    Wow lots of superb tips.

    does viagra help raynauds viagra sales online in uk
    viagra 100mg
    generic kamagra viagra – https://genericviagrarcp.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  60. Awaiting moderation

    Truly all kinds of terrific info!

    argentina made viagra brand name viagra by mail
    viagra generic
    pfizer stock quote before viagra – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  61. Awaiting moderation

    Whoa a lot of great knowledge!

    does viagra contain tadalafil viagra in holland
    generic viagra
    cialis vs viagra insomnia – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  62. Awaiting moderation

    Excellent material. Regards!

    discreet viagra viagra expiration date
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    walgreen viagra – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  63. Awaiting moderation

    Thank you. A lot of tips!

    samples of viagra apteekki viagra
    viagra for sale uk
    taking viagra with tramadol – https://genericviagramsl.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

  64. Awaiting moderation

    Thanks. An abundance of facts.

    online viagra prescriptions viagra examples
    buy viagra online
    generic viagra no prescriptio – https://genericviagrantx.com

    DavidCag
    TerenceJoido
    Victorboomy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2020 blog.bitmain.com

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑